Author information:
Lajos Ódor: Slovakian Budgetary Council , Member.
Gábor P. Kiss: MNB, Head of Department.
Abstract:
A proper fiscal framework should ensure fiscal sustainability while avoiding procyclicality of fiscal policy. As a prerequisite, fiscal rules should be based on numerical indicators that are conducive to both of these basic objectives. In this paper, we discuss problems that the existing European fiscal architecture fails to address, even as it becomes increasingly more complex and rule-based. We argue that a lack of robust, simple indicators makes the enforcement of rules and/or the prevention of procyclicality of fiscal policy very challenging. In our view, a decentralised framework would be better suited to fight against the deficit- bias in Europe. Accordingly, we propose that the first line of defence against irresponsible fiscal policy be provided by national, country-specific rules, with active monitoring of local fiscal councils. In this model, the community level would be responsible for checking compliance with minimum standards defined for local fiscal frameworks and for EU-wide coordination of policies instead of yearly fine-tuning of national budgets.
Cite as (APA):
Ódor, L., & P. Kiss, G. (2014). Back to basics – good indicators for good fiscal institutions! . Financial and Economic Review, 13(4), 125–151. https://hitelintezetiszemle.mnb.hu/en/6-odor-p-kiss-en
Column:
Peer-reviewed Paper
Journal of Economic Literature (JEL) codes:
E32, E62, H62, H63
Keywords:
fiscal framework, fiscal indicators, cyclical adjustment, fiscal council
References:
Barro, R. (1979): “On the Determination of the Public Debt”, Journal of Political Economy, university of Chicago Press, vol. 87(5), October 1979, pp. 940–71.
Blinder, A. (2004): The Quiet Revolution, Yale university Press.
Bornhorst, F., Dobrescu, G., Fedelino, A., Gottschalk, J. and Nakata, T. (2011): “when and How to Adjust Beyond the Business Cycle? A Guide to Structural Fiscal balances”, Technical notes and manuals, IMF, April 2011.
Boskin, M. J., Robinson, M. S. and Huber, A. M. (1987): “Government Saving, Capital Formation and wealth in the United States: 1947–1985”, NBER Working Paper 2352, August 1987.
Buiter, w. H. (1993): “Measurement of the Public Sector Deficit and Its Implication for Policy Evaluation and Design”, IMF Staff Papers, 30(2), pp. 306–49.
Buti, M. and Van den Noord, P. (2003): “Discretionary Fiscal Policy and Elections: The Experience of the Early Years of EMU”, OECD Working Papers 351.
Bouthevillain, C., Cour-Thimann, P., Van den Dool, G., Cos, P. H., Langenus, G., Mohr, M., Momigliano, S. and Tujula, M. (2001): “Cyclically Adjusted Budget Balances: An Alternative Approach”, European Central Bank Working Paper 77, September 2001.
Calmfors, L. and Wren-Lewis, S. (2011): “what Should Fiscal Councils Do?”, Department of Economics Discussion Paper Series, Oxford University.
Congressional Budget Office (2002): “The Standardized Budget and Other Adjusted Budget Measures”, April 2002.
Cheremukhin, A. (2013): “Estimating the Output Gap in Real Time”, Dallas FED Staff Papers 22, December 2013.
Cimadomo, J. (2008): “Fiscal Policy in Real Time”, European Central Bank Working Paper 919, July 2008.
Ize, A. (1993): “Measurement of Fiscal Performance in IMF-Supported Programs: Some Methodological Issues”, in Blejer, M. and Cheasty, A. (eds): How to Measure the Fiscal Deficit, Washington: IMF.
Denis, C., McMorrow, K. and Roeger, W. (2002): “Production function approach to calculating potential growth and output gaps – estimates for the EU Member States and the US”, Economic Papers 176, September 2002.
Diamond, J. and Schiller, C. (1993): “Government Arrears in Fiscal Adjustment Programs”, in Blejer, M. and Cheasty, A. (eds): How to Measure the Fiscal Deficit, Washington: IMF.
European Commission (2000): “Public finances in EMU – 2000”, Report of the Directorate for Economic and Financial Affairs, May 2000.
European Commission (2008): “Public Finances in EMU – 2008”. Brussels, European Economy 3.
European Commission, Economic and Financial Affairs (2014): “Cyclical Adjustment of Budget Balances” (http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/db_indicators/gen_gov_data/documents/2014/ccab_spring_en.pdf).
European Commission, Economic and Financial Affairs (2014): “Independent fiscal institutions in the EU Member States” (https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/db_indicators/fiscal_governance/independent_institutions/index_en.htm).
European Commission (2013): “Vade mecum on the Stability and Growth Pact”, Occasional Papers 151, May 2013.
Forni, L. and Momigliano, S. (2005): “Cyclical Sensitivity Of Fiscal Policies Based On Real- Time Data”. Applied Economics Quarterly 50(3), pp. 299–326.
GODIN, A. and KINSELLA, S. (2013): “Production Function at the Business End: The Case of the European Fiscal Compact”. Global and Local Economic Review 17(1), pp. 153–179.
Hagemann, R. (1999): “The Structural Budget Balance: The IMFs Methodology”. IMF Working Paper wP/99/95, July 1999.
Hoffmann, M. and P. Kiss, G. (2010): “From those lying facts to the underlying deficit”, MNB Bulletin, December 2010.
KESZT (2010): “A Költségvetési Elszámolások Szakértői Testülete (KESZT) javaslatai a költségvetési elszámolási szabályok megváltoztatására” (“The recommendations of the Expert Body on Budgetary Accounting /KESZT/ for changing budgetary accounting rules”) (http://www.freepress.nuzoka.com/download/000/297/reszletes.pdf).
Koen, V. and Van den Noord, P. (2005): “Fiscal Gimmickry in Europe: One-off Measures and Creative Accounting”, OECD Working Paper 417.
Langenus, G. (2013): “Comments on Session 4: Fiscal Tools to Control Macroeconomic Risks and Imbalances: Experiences and Prescriptions”, 15th workshop on Public Finance, organised by Banca d’Italia in Perugia from 4 to 6 April 2013.
Larch, M. and Turrini, A. (2009): “The cyclically-adjusted budget balance in EU fiscal policy making: A love at first sight turned into a mature relationship, Economic Papers 374, March 2009.
Lendvai, J., Moulin, L. and Turrini, a. (2011): “From CAB to CAAB? Correcting Indicators of Structural Fiscal Positions for Current Account Imbalances”, Economic Papers 442, April 2011.
Morris, R., Braz, C. R., De Castro, F., Jonk, S., Kremer, J., Linehan, S., Marino, M. R., Schalck, C. and Tkacevs, O. (2009): “Explaining government revenue windfalls and shortfalls: an analysis for selected EU countries”, ECB Working Papers 1114, November 2009.
Ódor, L. and P. Kiss, G. (2011): “The exception proves the rule? Fiscal rules in the Visegrád countries”, MNB Bulletin, June 2011.
Ódor, L. (2011): “Is It worth Considering Net worth? Fiscal Policy Frameworks for Central Europe Public Finance workshop”, Perugia, 31 March 2011–2 April 2011.
Ódor, L. (2014a): “The Good, the Bad and the ugly – Lessons from the first phase of implementation of the new European fiscal framework”. Council for Budget Responsibility, Discussion Paper 3.
Ódor, L. (2014b): “Another Quiet Revolution? Future role of independent fiscal institutions in Europe”. Council for Budget Responsibility, Discussion Paper, forthcoming.
Ódor, L. (2014c): “Fiscal Risk Assessment at the CBR: A Conceptual Framework Council for Budget Responsibility”. Discussion Paper 1.
Orphanides, A. and van Norden, S. (2002): “The unreliability of Inflation of Output Gap Estimates in Real Time”. The Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 84, pp. 569–83.
P. Kiss, G. and Vadas, G. (2006): “Filling the Gap – Measurement of the Cyclical Effect on Budgets”. 7th workshop on Public Finance, organised by Banca d’Italia in Perugia from 30 March to 1 April 2006.
P. Kiss, G. (2007): “Pain or Gain? Short-term Budgetary Effects of Surprise Inflation – the Case of Hungary”. MNB Occasional Papers 61.
Portes, J. and Wren-Lewis, S. (2014): “Issues in the Design of Fiscal Policy Rules”, Department of Economics Discussion Paper Series 704, university of Oxford.
Rocha, R. R. and Saldanha, F. (1992): “Fiscal and Quasi-Fiscal Deficit. Nominal and Real: Measurement and Policy Issues”, World Bank Working Paper, June 1992.
Stella, P. (1993): “Fiscal Impact of Public Enterprises”, IMF: How to Measure Fiscal Deficit.
Blejer, T. and Teijeiro, M. (1993): “Effects of Inflation on Measurement of Fiscal Deficits: Conventional Versus Operational Measures”, in Blejer, M. and Cheasty, A. (eds): How to Measure the Fiscal Deficit, Washington: IMF.
Tereanu, E., Tuladhar, A. and Alejandro, S. (2014): “Structural Balance Targeting and Output Gap uncertainty”, IMF Working Papers 14/107, June 2014.
Wattleworth, M. A. (1993): “Credit Subsidies in Budgetary Lending: Computation, Effects and Fiscal Implications”, in Blejer, M. and Cheasty, A. (eds): How to Measure the Fiscal Deficit, Washington: IMF.