Author information:
Csaba Csávás: Magyar Nemzeti Bank, Senior Economic Expert. E-mail: csavascs@mnb.hu
Gabriella Csom-Bíró: Magyar Nemzeti Bank, Analyst. E-mail: birog@mnb.hu
Abstract:
The paper examines to what extent usage of the foreign currency reserve adequacy indicators applied by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and investment banks can be mapped with those recommended in the academic literature. The theoretically relevant indicators differ substantially depending on the given country’s (1) development, (2) freedom of capital movement, and (3) exchange rate regime. In order to examine the question, the authors compiled a broad database, covering more than 100 countries, based on the IMF’s regular country reports. According to the results of the study, the IMF tends to use the short-term external debt and monetary aggregate indicators more often with the increase in income, while the role of the import rule gradually decreases as a function of income. There is a positive relation between the import rule and use of capital controls, while it is the other way round in the case of short-term external debt and the monetary aggregate indicators. For countries with a fixed exchange rate regime, the monetary aggregate and import indicators are used more often than for those with a floating exchange rate regime, while the use of short-term external debt is less frequent. The reserve indicators used for various combinations of country characteristics show group-specific features rather than being a simple aggregation of the indicators used for the individual country characteristics. The authors examined separately the group of countries of similar development level and exchange rate regime as Hungary, which do not apply capital controls, as well as the non-euro area region of the EU, where in its country reports the IMF assesses the reserve adequacy based on the self-elaborated composite metric – which attaches a high weight to short-term debt – on the one hand, and based on short-term external debt, on the other hand. However, the import rule and the monetary aggregate rules are less relevant or not relevant indicators. This differs substantially from the ratios reflected by the full sample, where – due to the large weight of the less developed countries – the IMF uses the import rule the most often. On the other hand, in investment banks’ analyses, short-term external debt is the indicator monitored with the greatest emphasis, both in the case of Hungary and the group of the emerging countries.
Cite as (APA):
Csávás, C., & Csom-Bíró, G. (2017). Indicators Used for the Assessment of the Reserve Adequacy of Emerging and Developing Countries – International Trendsin the Mirror of Theories. Financial and Economic Review, 16(1), 5–45. https://hitelintezetiszemle.mnb.hu/en/csaba-csavas-gabriella-csom-biro
Column:
Study
Journal of Economic Literature (JEL) codes:
E58, F31, F41
Keywords:
foreign exchange reserves, reserve indicator, capital control, exchange rate regime, country report
References:
Antal, J. – Gereben, Á. (2011): Foreign reserve strategies for emerging Economies − before and after the crisis. MNB Bulletin, April 2011, https://www.mnb.hu/letoltes/mnb-szemle-201104-hu.pdf, Downloaded: 7 February 2017.
Bank Zachodni WBK (2016): MACROscope, Polish Economy and Financial Markets. Grupa Santander, June, http://static3.bzwbk.pl/asset/m/_/e/m_eng_2016_06_62428.pdf, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Bussiere, M. – Cheng, G. – Chinn, M. D. – Lisack, N. (2015): For a few dollars more: Reserves and growth in times of crises. Journal of International Money and Finance, Vol. 52, April, pp. 127–145.
Calafell, J. G. – Padilla del Bosque, R. (2002): The ratio of International reserves to short-term external debt as an indicator of external vulnerability: some lessons from the experience of Mexico and other emerging economies. G24 Research Papers.
Chinn, M. D. – Ito, H. (2008): A New Measure of Financial Openness. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, Vol. 10, Issue 3, September:309–322.
Chinn, M. D. – Ito, H. (2016): Notes on The Chinn-Ito Financial Openness Index 2014 Update. http://web.pdx.edu/~ito/Chinn-Ito_website.htm, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Csávás, Cs. (2015): A devizatartalék-megfelelés értékelésének nemzetközi trendjei (International trends of assessing foreign exchange reserves adequacy). MNB, https://www.mnb.hu/letoltes/csavas-csaba-a-devizatartalek-megfeleles-ertekelesenek-nemzetkozi-trendjei.pdf, Downloaded: 7 February 2017
Csávás, Cs. – Csom-Bíró, G. (2016): Optimális tartalékmutatók – A rövid külső adósság szabály népszerűsége töretlen (Optimal reserve ratios – The popularity of the short-term external debt rule is undiminished). MNB, http://www.mnb.hu/letoltes/csavas-csaba-csom-biro-gabriella-optimalis-tartalekmutatok-a-rovid-kulso-adossag.pdf, Downloaded: 7 February 2017
Dabla-Norris, E. – Il Kim, J. – Shirono, K. (2011): Optimal Precautionary Reserves for Low-Income Countries: A Cost-Benefit Analysis. IMF Working Paper, Strategy, Policy, and Review Department, WP/11/249.
Deutsche Bank Research (2016): FX Reserves Adequacy in EM: who’s exposed?, Special Report, 22 November 2016. http://pull.db-gmresearch.com/cgi-bin/pull/DocPull/12070-09C8/203640069/DB_SpecialReport_2016-11-22_GDPBD00000302072.pdf. Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Euromoney (2015): Euromoney FX survey 2015 results revealed. http://www.euromoney.com/Article/3455276/Euromoney-FX-survey-2015-results-revealed.html, Downloaded: 7 February 2017
Farkas, P. (2010): Árfolyamrendszerek Közép- és Kelet-Európában (Exchange rate regimes in Central and Eastern Europe). Doctoral dissertation, http://ktk.pte.hu/sites/default/files/mellekletek/2014/07/Farkas_Peter_disszertacio.pdf, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Fitch Ratings (2012): Sovereign Rating Criteria. August, Fitch Ratings.
Franklin Templeton Investments (2015): Significant Slip – or Just a Blip – in Emerging Markets’ Foreign Exchange Reserves? Beyond Bulls &Bears Bulletin, Insight From Franklin Templeton Investments Managers, 28 April, http://www.franklintempleton.co.uk/downloadsServlet?docid=i941v9jo, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Furman, J. – Stiglitz E. J. (1998): Economic Crises: Evidence and Insights from East Asia. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Economic Studies Program, The Brookings Institution, vol. 29(2):1–136.
Goldman Sachs (2013): Two Decades of Freedom, What South Africa Is Doing With It, And What Now Needs To Be Done. Goldman Sachs, November, http://www.goldmansachs.com/our-thinking/archive/colin-coleman-south-africa/20-yrs-of-freedom.pdf, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Greenspan, A. (1999): Currency Reserves and Debt. Remarks before the World Bank Conference on Recent Trends in Reserves Management, Washington DC, April 29.
Guidotti, P. (1999): Remarks at G33 seminar in Bonn, Germany, 11 March.
Hanke, S. – Schuler, K. (2002): What went wrong in Argentina? Central Banking Journal, 12 (3), February:43–48.
HSBC Global Research (2014): Asian FX Policy Dashboard, USD purchases continue. Macro Currency Strategy, 19 May. https://www.research.hsbc.com/R/20/0VY9SChUfKlX. Downloaded: 6 January 2017
IMF (1958): International Reserves and Liquidity, A Study by the Staff of the International Monetary Fund. Washington DC, International Monetary Fund.
IMF (2000): Debt- and Reserve-Related Indicators of External Vulnerability. Prepared by the Policy Development and Review Department in consultation with other Departments, March 23.
IMF (2011): Assessing Reserve Adequacy. IMF Policy Paper, Monetary and Capital Markets, Research, and Strategy, Policy, and Review Departments, February.
IMF (2013): Assessing Reserve Adequacy – Further Considerations IMF Policy Paper, November.
IMF (2015): Assessing Reserve Adequacy – Specific Proposals. IMF Policy Paper, April.
IMF (2016): Guidance note on the assessment of reserve adequacy and related considerations.
JP Morgan (2016): Global FX reserve plunge continues; Hints of stabilization. May 2016, https://cib.jpmorgan.com/264622RMR/assets/0.pdf.img.ashx?Data=eaa1cff2c6353095a19e5e737fd6c800b8b3bc743fc70bf11236cd2e0f6e9400ac61ebb43c624163546adeec39600f03413097c90d488ce48cada20d726c1b4bfc51203aac86e3e3ea69b1d84c5e5aa9. Downloaded: 7 February 2017
Keynes, J. M. (1930): A Treatise on Money. In: Volume 2: The Applied Theory of Money. Reprinted in The Collected Works of John Maynard Keynes, volume 6, Macmillan/ Cambridge University Press, 1971.
Moody’s (2013): Rating Methodology – Sovereign Bond Ratings. September, Moody’s Investor Service.
Mwase, Nkunde (2012): How much should I hold? Reserve Adequacy in Emerging Markets and Small Islands. IMF Working Paper, Strategy Policy and Review Department, WP/12/205.
Obstfeld, M. – Shambaugh, J. C. – Taylor, Alan M. (2010): Financial Stability, the Trilemma, and International Reserves. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 2, April:57–94.
Odenius, J. – Rajan, A. (2013): Central Bank FX Reserve Adequacy, A Historical Perspective. http://www3.prudential.com/fi/pdf/prudential-fixed-income-centralbankfx-0913.pdf, Downloaded: 6 January 2017
Reinhart, C. – Calvo G. (2000): When Capital Inflows Come to a Sudden Stop: Consequences and Policy Options. University of Maryland, MPRA Paper No. 6982.
Rodrik, D. (2006): The Social Cost of Foreign Exchange Reserves. International Economic Journal Vol. 20, No. 3, September:253–266.
Rodrik, D. – Velasco, A. (1999): Short-Term Capital Flows. NBER Working Papers 7364, National Bureau of Economic Research, September.
Roy, R. – Ramos, R. A. (2012): IMF Article IV Reports: An Analysis of Policy Recommendations. International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth (IPC-IG), Working Paper 86.
S&P Global Ratings (2014): Sovereign Rating Methodology. December 2014, Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services.
Thornton, H. (1802): An Enquiry into the Nature and Effects of the Paper Credit of Great Britain. London: George Allen and Unwin, 1939.
UBS (2015): Global Macro Strategy Theme #1: EM enters a new, dangerous phase. https://neo.ubs.com/shared/d11J3RYV1uEkGEa/, Downloaded: 7 February 2017
Wijnholds, J. O. de Beaufort – Kapteyn, A. (2001): Reserve Adequacy in Emerging Market Economies. IMF Working Papers, Office of Executive Directors, WP/01/143.